Is the Authority to Bind and Loose Unique to Catholic Priests?

Apr 29, 2025

The authority to "bind and loose" - a concept deeply rooted in first-century Jewish tradition - remains one of the most discussed aspects of church authority and discipline. These words of Jesus, recorded in Matthew 16:19 and Matthew 18:18, have profound implications for how we understand spiritual authority, forgiveness, and church leadership. The phrase "Whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven" has shaped Christian doctrine and practice from the early church to modern times.

This power, originally understood as doctrinal and disciplinary authority rather than mystical priestly essence, was given first to Peter and then extended to the gathered church. While Catholic tradition sees these verses as the foundation for sacramental confession and apostolic succession, Protestant theology emphasizes the priesthood of all believers and direct access to God's forgiveness through Christ. Both interpretations raise important questions about the nature of spiritual authority and its exercise within the Christian community.

In this brief exploration, we'll examine how these ancient words echo from the halls of rabbinical schools to today's churches, considering their original context, various interpretations, and practical implications for modern believers. Our journey through this topic invites us to carefully discern God's design for authority, forgiveness, and spiritual leadership in His church.

Historical and Rabbinic Background

To understand the concept of "binding and loosing" in its historical context, we must first examine its roots in Jewish tradition. In rabbinic practice, these terms (asar for "binding" and hittir for "loosing") were carefully used by religious scholars known as posekim to make authoritative decisions about religious practices. These decisions encompassed various aspects of daily life, from dietary regulations to Sabbath observances.

Consider, for instance, how a rabbi might exercise this authority: they could *"bind" (*prohibit) the use of certain utensils during Shabbat or "loose" (permit) specific activities that were previously questioned. These determinations carried significant weight within the community, as a binding decision was considered definitive, while a loosing decision provided clear permission for the faithful.

When Jesus spoke to Peter, saying, "I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven; whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven" (Matthew 16:19), He was drawing upon this well-established tradition. He later extended this authority to the wider group of apostles, stating, "Truly I tell you, whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven" (Matthew 18:18). It's important to note that in first-century Judaism, this language of binding and loosing was understood primarily as an expression of legal and teaching authority, rather than supernatural power (Craig, 2021; Logos Bible Study, 2021). Through these words, Jesus graciously invited His followers to participate in His governance of the faith community, always under the authority of heaven.

Scriptural Exegesis of ‘Binding and Loosing’

When Jesus entrusts Peter with "the keys of the kingdom" in Matthew 16:19, He is drawing on this rabbinic imagery to describe the steward-like role Peter would play in the nascent church (Waters, n.d.). The "keys" symbolize authority to teach, to guard sound doctrine, and to exercise church discipline under heaven's sanction. Two chapters later, Jesus reiterates the same promise to "you" (plural)—all who gather in His name—underscoring that this authority extends beyond an individual to the corporate body of Christ (Matthew 18:18) (Desiring God, 2018).

The apostle Peter then broadens this truth in 1 Peter 2:9, declaring believers "a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation" with direct access to the Father (1 Pet 2:9). Here the binding and loosing motif culminates in the universal priesthood: every believer is called to offer spiritual sacrifices—prayer, praise, and proclamation—without intermediaries GotQuestions.org Precept Austin.

John 20:23 further states*, "If you forgive the sins of any, their sins have been forgiven them"* (John 20:23). While this verse relates to the church's ministry of reconciliation (Ligonier, n.d.), it must be understood in light of God's unique authority to forgive sins. Scripture consistently affirms this divine prerogative: "Who can forgive sins but God alone?" (Mark 2:7), and "I, even I, am he who blots out your transgressions" (Isaiah 43:25).

This vision unites all strands of the biblical narrative: the keys of the kingdom are wielded not by arcane ritual but by Spirit-empowered proclamation (kerygma) of the gospel (Rom 10:14–15), corporate discipline that mirrors divine justice (Matt 18:15–17), and the shared priesthood that draws all people into covenant fellowship (1 Pet 2:9–10). Unlike the binding and loosing passages, John 20:23 does not establish a separate priestly class with divine authority but rather empowers Christ's followers to proclaim His forgiveness through the gospel. This understanding invites us to consider: was Jesus establishing a unique, perpetual office with quasi-divine power, or commissioning His followers to declare the forgiveness that He alone can grant?

Catholic Interpretation and the Sacrament of Penance

Roman Catholic theology reads these passages together as the scriptural foundation for the sacrament of Penance, wherein a duly ordained priest—as the successor of the apostles—acts "in persona Christi" to forgive sins (Staples, 2024). The Catechism (¶ 553) draws on both Matthew and John to affirm that Christ conferred on the apostles—and through them on their successors—the authority to forgive sins, designed to safeguard doctrinal unity and moral order (Catholic Productions, 2020). In practice, this has been exercised through the rite of Confession, where penitents confess sins to a priest, receive absolution, and perform acts of penance - a practice that even appears to undermine the complete sufficiency of Christ's once-for-all sacrifice on the cross (Heschmeyer, 2023). While Eastern Catholic traditions, like the Eparchy of Edmonton, emphasize that the priest's absolution pronounces Christ's forgiveness (Eparchy of Edmonton, 2021), critics caution that such an interpretation risks attributing to clergy a quasi-divine essence separate from Christ's unique mediatorship (Integrated Catholic Life™).

Protestant Perspective and the Priesthood of All Believers

Many Protestant traditions affirm that Christ alone forgives sins and that the privilege of binding and loosing belongs to all believers through the proclamation of the gospel and mutual church discipline (Christian Courier, n.d.). They emphasize that forgiveness comes through direct repentance to God, mediated solely by Christ: "For there is one God and one Mediator between God and humanity, Christ Jesus" (1 Timothy 2:5). As Scripture affirms, "If we confess our sins, He is faithful and righteous to forgive us our sins" (1 John 1:9).

They argue that John 20:23 does not prescribe a distinct clerical class with intrinsic divine power; rather, it entrusts the gospel ministry—and its reconciling authority—to the whole body of Christ (GotQuestions.org, 2022). Reformed scholars note that the authority in Matthew 18:18 extends to the gathered disciples as a body, illustrating communal responsibility rather than a clerical monopoly. The Heidelberg Catechism interprets the "keys" as the preaching of the Word and the exercise of Christian discipline to open and close the kingdom to faith or persistent unbelief (Ligonier, n.d.). In this view, the "binding" and "loosing" of sins is first and foremost the proclamation of Christ's atoning work, rather than a juridical exercise by a priestly caste.

Pause for Reflection

As we reflect on this topic, several important questions emerge. First, we should consider how our understanding of the rabbinic background of "bind and loose" enriches our perspective on church authority. This historical context provides crucial insights into the nature and purpose of spiritual leadership. Furthermore, we must examine how our recognition of Christ's unique divinity shapes our approach to church discipline and forgiveness, ensuring our practices remain centered on His authority rather than human power. The relationship between ordained ministry and biblical teaching also deserves careful consideration - particularly regarding the risks of elevating church leaders beyond their scriptural roles and how to maintain appropriate boundaries. Finally, we should explore practical ways for every believer to exercise the "keys" through active participation in proclamation, prayer, and mutual accountability within the church community.

Conclusion

Jesus entrusted His followers with the authority to "bind" and "loose," not to establish a quasi-divine priesthood, but to empower His body to uphold truth, exercise loving discipline, and extend grace. While human traditions and hierarchical systems may attempt to claim exclusive rights to this authority, we must remain faithful to the biblical pattern that empowers all believers in the ministry of reconciliation. As followers of Christ, we are called to separate ourselves from man-made religious systems that elevate human authority above Scripture and create artificial barriers between God and His people.

Let us stand firm against philosophies and traditions that would bind our consciences to human intermediaries rather than to Christ alone. May we approach this sacred commission with humility and clarity, maintaining pure devotion to Christ while rejecting any system that would usurp His unique role as our High Priest. In doing so, we proclaim and embody the direct access to forgiveness that flows only from our risen Lord, unencumbered by human institutions that would seek to control or limit God's grace.

Recommended Articles

Further Resources

Explore Online Ministry Opportunities at Open Christian Ministries (USA)
Explore Christian Business Services at the Center for Faith and Work (Rwanda)
Pursue an Affordable Online Christian Degree at Open Christian University (USA)
Stay updated and connect with our community by subscribing to our email list Here
Kindly Share Your Question for Consideration in Future Articles. Click Here to Submit
Ask a Question or Utilize Our Trained AI Bot to Craft Your Evangelical Article - Begin Here
Access Educational Videos in Kinyarwanda at Center for Faith and Work or in English at Open Christian Ministries.